SSR Inst. Int. J. Life Sci., 10(1): 3582-3589, Jan 2024
Evaluation of Clinical and Biochemical Parameters in Organophosphorus
Poisoning
Srikant Kumar Behera1, Sunita Sethy2, Kailash Chandra Dash3*, Suresh Kumar Rout4, Purna
Chandra Dash5
1Post PG Doctor, Dept. of Medicine, DHH, Cuttack,
Odisha, India
2Assistant
Professor, Dept. of Medicine, SCB MCH, Cuttack, Odisha, India
3Reader, Oral & Maxillofacial Pathology, Kalinga
Institute of Dental Sciences, KIIT Deemed to be University Bhubaneswar, Odisha,
India
4Assistant
Professor, Dept. of Radiotherapy, VIMSAR, Burla, Odisha, India
5Professor,
Dept. of Medicine, SCB MCH, Cuttack, Odisha, India
*Address for
Correspondence: Dr. Kailash Chandra Dash, Reader, Oral & Maxillofacial Pathology,
Kalinga Institute of Dental Sciences, KIIT Deemed to be University Bhubaneswar,
Odisha, India
E-mail: sunitasethy100@gmail.com
ABSTRACT- Background: Organophosphorus (OP) poisoning
is a significant health issue in developing countries like India due to the
easy availability and low cost of OP compounds, leading to a rise in suicidal
and accidental poisonings. With agriculture contributing substantially to the
Indian economy, the use of OP compounds is extensive, making up 22% of the GDP
and employing nearly 70% of the workforce. This study addresses the pressing
need to understand factors influencing the morbidity and mortality associated
with OP poisoning.
Methods: A study was conducted, including
100 consecutive patients admitted to the PG Dept. of Medicine at SCB Medical
College between December 2020 and November 2021 with documented
organophosphorus poisoning. Parameters were examined, such as the type and
quantity of OP compounds consumed, the time between exposure and gastric
lavage, clinical severity grading, and their correlations with mechanical
ventilation, complications, and mortality.
Results: Chlorpyriphos (29%), Phorate (26%), and Dimethoate (13%) were the most common OP
compounds used. Complications included pulmonary edema (31.8%), aspiration
pneumonia (22.7%), respiratory failure (27.2%), and intermediate syndrome
(18.3%). Non-survivors had a significantly higher mean poison consumption
(116.66ml) compared to survivors (42.92ml).
Conclusion: The study concludes that the mean
amount of poison consumed is indicative of complications and mortality in OP
poisoning. Additionally, the time interval between ingestion and gastric lavage
is a valuable indicator for assessing the severity of poisoning, predicting
complications, and estimating the need for ventilator support and mortality
risk. These findings contribute to refining management strategies for OP
poisoning cases.
Key Words: Organophosphorus, OP poisoning, POP scale, Clinical
parameters, Biochemical parameters
Therefore, serum lipase estimation may be helpful
for an early diagnosis of pancreatitis in patients with increased amylase
levels. A patient's chance of dying from OP poisoning increases if they consume
50 100 ml or more of the OP compounds; eating more than 100 ml has the highest
death rate. [14], when post-poisoning care begins [15],
which patients require mechanical breathing [16], and how long
ventilator support is needed [17]. Longer automatic breathing times
are also needed for those with extended lag periods. [17] This study
aims to investigate potential correlations between the amount of poison
consumed, the time interval between the poisoning and gastric lavage, and
various biochemical parameters such as serum choline esterase, serum amylase,
serum lipase, serum urea, and serum creatinine values, and the severity,
complications, ventilator requirement, and mortality in cases of OP poisoning.
The kind and amount of OP compound consumed, the interval between exposure to
the poison and the time of gastric lavage, the clinical severity as determined
by the Peradeniya OP poisoning scale, the need for and length of time spent on
mechanical ventilation, complications, and death from OP poisoning are among
the variables that need to be looked into.
MATERIALS
AND METHODS- In this
prospective study conducted at the Department of Medicine, SCB Medical College,
and Cuttack from December 2020 to November 2021, 100 patients diagnosed with OP
poisoning were enrolled following approval from the Institute Ethical
Committee. The study design included all OP poisoning cases, with specific
exclusion criteria applied. The participants' demographic and clinical
information were collected through established medical examinations and
laboratory tests. Ethical considerations were addressed with IEC approval,
ensuring participant confidentiality and well-being. Statistical analysis was
conducted to analyze the collected data. The study aimed to comprehensively
investigate OP poisoning, utilizing a rigorous methodology to derive meaningful
insights.
Inclusion
criteria- The study
included all the OP poisoning cases diagnosed by history, circumstantial
evidence of consumption, characteristic clinical features, and basic laboratory
investigations.
Exclusion criteria
Patients
less than 15 years.
Poisoning
with substances other than organophosphorus compound or OP compound mixed with
other substances.
Patients
who have chronic alcoholism
Patients
with a history of pancreatitis or disease of the salivary gland
Patients
with history of any disease that may adversely affect the outcome in case of op
poisoning.
Statistical Analysis- In this study, a comprehensive approach was employed to evaluate and
manage patients with organophosphate (OP) poisoning. Detailed histories were
obtained from the patient's relatives, covering the type of OP compound and
treatment history. A thorough clinical examination focused on vital parameters,
pupil size, and assessments of the central nervous, respiratory,
cardiovascular, and gastrointestinal systems. The Peradeniya OP poisoning scale
was applied at admission to grade the severity of OP poisoning. Diagnosis
relied on clinical features, exposure history, and low plasma
pseudocholinesterase levels. Standard protocols, including atropine,
pralidoxime, and supportive measures, were administered. Baseline
investigations were performed, such as complete blood count, plasma
pseudocholinesterase, blood urea, serum creatinine, amylase, and lipase.
Follow-up assessments included the reassessment of certain parameters on days 3
and 5. Arterial blood gas and chest X-rays were conducted in ventilated
patients, while ultrasound examinations were performed in cases showing signs
of pancreatitis or renal failure. Data analysis encompassed age, gender, amount
of OP consumed, time intervals, ventilatory support, hospital stay,
complications, and outcomes. Statistical analysis was conducted using the
Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) software, ensuring the integrity
and completeness of the collected data.
Ethical approval- The patients and their attendants were informed about the study objectives, procedures, risks and benefits related to the study. In addition, they were told that participation was optional, and will not affect the treatment outcome during their stay in the hospital.
RESULTS- The mean age of presentation for patients in this study was 37.57 16.19
years for males and 34.28 13.44 years for females. Most cases were in the
younger age group, with 28 out of 100 patients falling between 21 and 30 years
of age, followed by 15 patients in the 15 20-year range. Distribution across
other age groups included 25, 11, and 12 cases in the 31-40-, 41-50-, and 51
60-year ranges, respectively. Only 9 patients were over 60, as highlighted in
Table 1. This demographic breakdown provides insight into the age distribution
of patients presenting with organophosphate poisoning in the study population.
Table
1: Age
distribution
Age (Yrs) |
Males |
Females |
||
Frequency
(N) |
Percentage
(%) |
Frequency (N) |
Percentage (%) |
|
<20 |
07 |
13 |
08 |
17.4 |
21 to 30 |
16 |
29.6 |
12 |
26.1 |
31 to 40 |
11 |
20.4 |
14 |
30.4 |
41 to 50 |
05 |
9.3 |
06 |
13.0 |
51 to 60 |
09 |
16.7 |
03 |
6.5 |
>60 |
06 |
11.1 |
03 |
6.5 |
Total |
54 |
100 |
46 |
100 |
The study findings reveal that chlorpyriphos was the predominant
organophosphate (OP) compound used in cases of poisoning, accounting for 29 out
of 100 instances. Phorate followed closely,
comprising 26% of the cases, while dimethoate was associated with 13% of
poisonings. Other OP compounds identified included dichlorvos, profenofos, monocrotophos, diphos, and acephate. Notably, in
8% of the cases, the specific poison compound could not be determined, as
detailed in Table 2 and Fig 1. This information underscores the distribution of
various OP compounds responsible for poisoning incidents in the study
population, with chlorpyriphos being the most prevalent.
Table 2: Types of
compounds consumed
Type of compound consumed |
Frequency (N) |
Percentage (%) |
Chlorpyriphos |
29 |
29 |
Diphorate |
06 |
6 |
Monocrotophos |
04 |
4 |
Phorate |
26 |
26 |
Malathion |
02 |
2 |
Dimethoate |
13 |
13 |
Profenofos |
03 |
3 |
Acephate |
01 |
1 |
Diphos |
03 |
3 |
Unknown |
08 |
8 |
Total |
100 |
100 |
Table 3:
Presenting features
Clinical features |
Males (%) |
Females (%) |
Total |
Sludge* |
49 (90.7) |
43 (93.5) |
92 (92) |
Miosis |
41 (75.9) |
32 (69.6) |
73 (73) |
Tachypnea |
40 (74.1) |
29 (63.) |
69 (69) |
Bronchorrhea |
36 (66.7) |
26 (56.5) |
62 (62) |
Bradycardia |
35 (64.8) |
27 (58.7) |
62 (62) |
Tachycardia |
02 (3.7) |
04 (8.7) |
06 (6) |
Fasciculation |
07 (13.) |
01 (2.2) |
08 (8) |
Altered sensorium |
39 (72.2) |
27 (58.7) |
66 (66) |
Seizure |
05 (9.3) |
02 (4.3) |
07 (7) |
Coma |
07 (13.) |
03 (6.5) |
10 (10) |
During
the study of symptoms and signs at the time of admission and hospitalization,
SLUDGE* (salivation, lacrimation, urination, diarrhoea,
GI upset and emesis) was the most common symptom present in 92% of the cases,
while miosis (73%), tachypnoea (69%), altered sensorium (66%), bronchorrhea
(62%) and bradycardia (62%) were common presenting signs followed by coma
(10%), fasciculation (8%) and seizure (7%), Tachycardia (6%).
Table 4: Complications
Frequency (N) |
Percentage (%) |
|
Pulmonary edema |
14 |
31.8 |
Aspiration pneumonia |
10 |
22.7 |
Respiratory failure |
12 |
27.2 |
Intermediate syndrome |
08 |
18.3 |
Total |
44 |
100 |
Table 5: Amount of
poison consumed.
Amount consumed (in mL) |
Frequency (N) |
Percentage (%) |
<25 |
33 |
33 |
26 to 50 |
30 |
30 |
51 to 75 |
16 |
16 |
76 to 100 |
09 |
9 |
>100 |
12 |
12 |
Total |
100 |
100 |
The mean consumption of poison in males was
52.77ml, while in females, it was 60.21ml. Most cases (63%) consumed less than
50ml of the poison.
Fig. 1:
Amount of poison consumed v/s outcome
Fig. 2: Amount of
poison consumed v/s complications observed during study
Fig. 3: Amount of
poison consumed v/s occurrence of IMS during study.
Fig. 4: Distribution
of patients according to severity of op poisoning based on pop scale.
Table 6: Severity of
POP score Vs mean interval of presentation.
Time interval (hrs) |
POP score |
p-value |
Pearson s
Chi- square (χ) |
||
Mild (%) |
Moderate (%) |
Severe (%) |
<0.001 |
97.769 |
|
<1 |
10 (29.4) |
02 (3.6) |
01 (10) |
||
1 to 2 |
17 (50.0) |
01 (1.8) |
00 |
||
2 to 3 |
01 (2.9) |
28 (50) |
01 (10) |
||
3 to 4 |
06 (17.6) |
21 (37.5) |
01 (10) |
||
>5 |
00 |
04 (7.1) |
07 (70) |
||
Total |
34 (100) |
56 (100) |
10 (100) |
Among
the patients presented with mild poisoning (34), in 27 cases (79.4%), gastric
lavage was done before 2 hours, while only in 7 (20.5%) cases gastric lavage
was done after 2 hours. Among the moderate poisoning cases (56), in 49 cases
(87.5%), gastric lavage was done between 2-4 hours, while in 3(5.4%) and 4
(7.1%) cases, gastric lavage was done before 2 hours and after 4 hours
respectively. Among 10 patients with severe poisoning, in 7 (70%) patients,
gastric lavage was done after 4 hours; in the rest, 3 (30%), it was done before
4 hours. The time interval between ingestion of poison and gastric lavage has a
highly significant association with the severity of poisoning, as indicated by
p-value <0.001.
DISCUSSION- The study sample consisted of 100 patients, with a
mean age of presentation of 34.28 13.44 years for females and 37.57 16.19 years
for males. Twenty patients were in the age range of twenty to twenty, and
fifteen patients fell into the fifteen to twenty age range. These patients made
up the bulk of those in the younger age group. There were 25 cases in the age
ranges of 31 40, 41 50, and 51 60 years, respectively. There were also 11 cases
and 12 cases. The number of patients above sixty was just nine. The younger age
groups were, therefore, more likely to suffer from OP poisoning and contemplate
suicide because of their emotional immaturity and inability to cope with
stressful events such as romantic relationships and exams. Rangaswamy et al. [18]
and Logaraj et al. [19] presented similar findings from their
experiments in 2017. In our investigation, male cases accounted for 54% of all
cases; the male-to-female ratio was 1.17. Men encounter stress in their lives
more often than women, which could make them less skilled at managing it. This
could help to clarify things. Studies by Vikram et al. [20] and
Shobha et al. [21] provided evidence in favor of it. However, the
findings of Bag et al. [22] analysis differed. Suicidal tendencies
characterized most poisoning cases in our sample, which is consistent with
research by Vikram et al. [23] and Bhattarai et al. [24].
Due to their easy availability of these chemicals and propensity to act on
suicidal impulses, farmers are more prone to suffer from suicide poisoning.
Based on epidemiological distribution, 76% of the population resided in rural
areas. This outcome was consistent with the findings of Gupta et al. [25].
Op chemicals are commonly used in agriculture, which could explain why this
group is more likely to come across them in rural areas and make them easier to
purchase there. Out of the 100 compounds studied, chlorpyriphos was the most
frequently used type of substance (29 instances); it was closely followed by
dimethoate (13%) and phenol (26%). In addition, acephate,
phorate, dichlorvos, profenofos,
diphos, and monocrotophos
were consumed as OP compounds. Of the patients, 8% had an unknown dangerous
chemical. 30.17% of cases in the Zanjad and Nanadkar [26] study is attributed to monocrotophos. Quinolphos and
methyl parathion follow monocrotophos in the
percentage of instances, with 18.96% and 28.44%, respectively.
On
average, men drank 52.77 ml of poison, while women drank 60.21 ml. Less than 50
milliliters of the poison were consumed in 63% of the instances. Survivors
consumed 42.92 ml of poison on average, while non-survivors ingested 116.66 ml.
The p-value of 0.006 indicates that there is a significant difference between
them. Therefore, there may be a positive correlation between the mean amount
consumed and the outcome in the case of op poisoning. On the Peradeniya OP
poisoning scale, the majority of patients in our study (56%) were classified as
moderately poisoned, followed by the mild group (34%) and the severe group
(10%). Bhattacharya et al. discovered similar outcomes in their study. In
Prakash et al. [27] study, the bulk of patients were categorized as
mild, and this group had a higher frequency of unintended ingestion. Seven of
the 34 patients (79.4%) who had mild poisoning had stomach lavage performed
after two hours, while the other 27 (79.4%) had it done sooner. Of the
fifty-six patients with mild poisoning, forty-nine (87.5%) underwent gastric
lavage within the two to four-hour timeframe; four (7.1%) and three (5.4%)
underwent gastric lavage before the two-hour interval. Of the ten patients who
experienced severe poisoning, three (30%) and seven (7%), respectively, had
gastric lavage performed earlier and later than four hours later. There was a
statistically significant correlation (p<0.001) between the degree (as
measured by the POP scale) and the amount of time that passed between
swallowing the toxin and performing a stomach lavage. During the hospital stay,
92% of the patients experienced SLUDGE (salivation, lacrimation, urine, diarrhoea, GI upset, and emesis) as their most often
observed symptom when symptoms and signs were evaluated at admission. Other
prevalent presenting symptoms were tachypnea (69%), altered sensorium (66%),
miosis (73%), bronchorrhea (62%), and bradycardia (62%). 10% of patients are in
a coma, 8% have fasciculations, 7% have seizures, and 6% have tachycardia. A
similar tendency was described by Goel et
al. [28].
CONCLUSIONS- The study draws significant conclusions regarding organophosphate (OP)
poisoning. It suggests that the mean amount of poison consumption can serve as
a predictor for the occurrence of complications and mortality in OP poisoning
cases. Additionally, the time interval between poison ingestion and gastric
lavage is valuable for assessing the severity of poisoning, predicting
complications, determining the need for ventilator support, and estimating
mortality risk. The severity of poisoning, as per the Peradeniya OP poisoning
scale, is found to have a significant positive association with the occurrence
of intermediate syndrome, the duration of hospitalization, the need and
duration of ventilator support, and mortality in OP poisoning cases.
These findings contribute
valuable insights into the factors influencing the outcomes and complications
associated with OP poisoning, aiding in better understanding, and managing this
condition.
Research concept- Srikant
Kumar Behera, Purna Chandra, Dash, Sunita Sethy, Suresh Kumar Rout
Research design- Sunita
Sethy
Supervision- Sunita Sethy
Materials- Srikant Kumar Behera, Purna Chandra, Dash, Sunita
Sethy, Suresh Kumar Rout
Data collection- Srikant
Kumar Behera, Purna Chandra, Dash, Sunita Sethy, Suresh Kumar Rout
Data analysis and Interpretation- Srikant
Kumar Behera, Purna Chandra, Dash
Literature search- Srikant
Kumar Behera, Purna Chandra, Dash
Writing article- Sunita
Sethy
Critical review- Sunita
Sethy, Suresh Kumar Rout
Article editing- Sunita
Sethy, Suresh Kumar Rout
Final approval- Suresh
Kumar Rout
REFERENCES
1. Kumar V, Fareedullah MD et al. Current review on Organophosphorus
poisoning. Arch Appl Sci Res., 2010; 2: 199 215.
2. Eddleston M. Patterns and problems of deliberate self-poisoning
in the developing world. QJM, 2000; 93: 715 31.
3. Pore NE, Pujari KN, Jadkar
SP. Organophosphorus poisoning. J Pharma Biosci.,
2011; 2: 604 12.
4. Lotti M, Moretto A. Cholinergic symptoms and Gulf
War syndrome. Nat Med., 1995; 1: 1225 26.
5. Singh G, Khurana D. Neurology of acute
organophosphate poisoning. Neurol India, 2009; 57: 119 25.
6. Anormallikleri L. Emergency laboratory abnormalities in suicidal
patients with acute organophosphate poisoning. T rk Biyokimya Dergisi., 2010; 35(1):
29-34.
7. Mehta AB, Shah AC, Joshi LG, Kale AK, et al.
Clinical features and plasma acetylcholinesterase activity in poisoning with
insecticidal organophosphorus compounds. J Assoc Physicians India, 1991; 19:
181 84.
8. Goswamy R, Chaudhuri A, Mahashur
AA. Study of respiratory failure in organophosphate and carbamate poisoning.
Heart Lung, 1994; 23: 466 72.
9. Senthilnathan NK, Allen Binny. Biochemical
abnormalities in OPC poisoning and its prognostic significance, IOSR-JDMS,
2017; 16(7): 116-19.
10. Oxford text book of medicine 5th
edition, 2012- David A Warell, Timmothy Cox, John d
Firth. Available at: https://academic.oup.com/ije/article/42/5/1524/620847.
11. Dressel T, GoodaleJr R,
Arneson M, Borner J. Pancreatitis as a complication of anticholinesterase
insecticide intoxication. Annals of surgery. 1999; 189(2):199.
12. Matsumiya N, Tanaka M, Iwai M, Kondo T, Takahashi S, Sato S.
Elevated amylase is related to the development of respiratory failure in
organophosphate poisoning. Hum Exp Toxicol., 1996;
15: 250 53.
13. Lee HS. Acute pancreatitis and organophosphate
poisoning. A case report and review. Singapore Med J., 1999; 30: 599 601.
14. Banday TH, Tathineni B,
Desai MS, Naik V. Predictors of Morbidity and Mortality in Organophosphorus
Poisoning: A Case Study in Rural Hospital in Karnataka, India. N Am J Med Sci.,
2015; 7(6): 259-65. doi: 10.4103/1947-2714.159331.
15. Suleman MI, Jibran R, Rai M. The analysis of
organophosphate poisoning case treated at Bhawal
Victoria Hospital, Bahawalpur 2000-2003. Pak J Med Sci., 2006; 22: 244 49.
16. Hussain AM, Sultan ST. Organophosphorus insecticide
poisoning: Management in surgical intensive care unit. J Coll Physicians Surg
Pak., 2005; 15: 100 02.
17. Wadia RS. Treatment of organophosphate poisoning.
Indian J Crit Care Med., 2003; 17: 85 87.
18. Rangaswamy, M S Bharath. A study of cardiac
involvement in organophosphorus poisoning. IJSS, 2018; 5(10): 38-40.
19. Logaraj M, Ethirajan N, Felix JW, Roseline FW.
Suicidal attempts reported at a medical college hospital in Tamilnadu.
Indian J Comm Med., 2005; 30(4): 136-37.
20. Vikram P, Arun M, Saralaya
KM, Bhoopendra S. Spectrum of organophosphorous
poisoning in Manipal. Ind Medica-Medicolegal Update, 2005; 5(2): 55-57.
21. Shobha TR, Prakash O. Glycosuria in organophosphate
and carbamate poisoning. J Assoc Physicians India, 2000; 48(12): 1197-99.
22. Bag A, Ghosh K., Bhattacharya A, Ghosh S. A study
of changes in liver function, pancreatic enzyme levels, and creatine
phosphokinase level in cases of acute organophosphorus poisoning. Toxicol Int., 2015; 22(3): 70-75.
23. Vikram P, Arun M, Saralaya
KM, Bhoopendra S. Spectrum of organophosphorous
poisoning in Manipal. Ind Medica-Medicolegal Update, 2005; 5(2): 55-57.
24. Bhattarai N, Rewniyar A,
Chaudhry D, Jaiswal S, Banthia P, Rana BB. Patterns of organophosphorus
poisoning attending a teaching hospital. J Nepal Med Assoc., 2006; 45(162):
228-32.
25. Gupta B, et al. Organophosphorus poisoning facts
and myths. Med Update, 1999; pp. 1345 48.
26. Zanjad NP, Nanadkar SD. Study
of sudden unexpected deaths in medicolegal autopsies. J Ind Acad
Forensic Med., 2006; 28(1): 27-30.
27. Prakash M, Ram O, Harsh DS. Acute Organophosphorus
Poisoning and Clinical Admission Score Association Among Patients Admitted In
Emergency Ward Of A Tertiary Teaching Hospital Of Medical College. J Pharm
Biomed Sci., 2012; 17(8): 1-5.
28. Goel A, Joseph S. Dutta TK. Organophosphate
poisoning: predicting the need for ventilatory support. JAPI, 1998; 46: 786-90.