Research Article (Open access) |
---|
SSR Inst. Int. J. Life Sci., 9(1): 3162-3172, January 20223
Effectiveness
of VATP on Use of Lamaze
Breathing Exercise during First Stage of Labour Process among Staff
Nurses
Shruti Maddur1*, Jayashri Awarasang1,
Deelip Somaninga Natekar2
1M.Sc Student, Dept. of Obstetrical and Gynaecological Nursing, Shri B.V.V.S Sajjalashree Institute of Nursing Sciences, Navanagar, Bagalkot,
Karnataka, India
1Associate Professor Dept. of Obstetrical and Gynaecological Nursing,
Shri B.V.V.S Sajjalashree Institute of Nursing Sciences, Navanagar, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India
2Principal, Shri B.V.V.S Sajjalashree Institute of Nursing
Sciences, Navanagar, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India
*Address for Correspondence: Ms.
Shruti Maddur, M.Sc Nursing II year, Dept. of obstetrical and Gynaecological Nursing, Shri B.V.V.S
Sajjalashree Institute of Nursing
Sciences, Navanagar, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India
E-mail: shrutimaddur93@gmail.com
ABSTRACT Background: Lamaze breathing is a breathing
technique based on the idea that controlled breathing can enhance relaxation
and decrease the perception of pain. Some of the important techniques for
controlled breathing include slow, deep breathing. Pregnancy and childbirth is one of the greatest events in the life of a
woman which she aspires and longs for with great expectation.
Methods:
The data were collected by using the
structured close-ended knowledge questionnaire. From using the disproportional
stratified random technique of 50 staff nurses. Attending HSK and Daddenavara
hospital, Bagalkot in a pre-experimental survey. The data was analysed by using
descriptive and inferential statistics in terms of mean, frequency
distribution, percentage, paired t-test and chi-square test.
Results: In post-test reveals that out of 50 staff
nurses, the highest post-test (40%) of staff nurses had good knowledge, (30%)
had excellent knowledge followed percentage (30%) of staff nurses with average
knowledge. The overall findings reveal that the post-test knowledge score
(30.54±5.66), which was (72.88%) of the total score was more when compared to
the pre-test knowledge score (13±4.61), which was (36.05%) total score. The
effectiveness of VATP in this area was a mean knowledge score of 17 with
SD±1.04, which was (36.83%) of the total score. The
calculated 't' value (17.77) was much higher than the table valve (1.96) for
the degree of freedom 49 and 0.05% level of significance.
Conclusion: The study provides that a video-assisted
teaching programme on knowledge regarding the use of Lamaze breathing exercises
among staff nurses was a scientific, logical, and cost-effective strategy.
Keywords: Effectiveness,
Knowledge, Staff nurses, Lamaze breathing exercise, VATP
INTRODUCTION- Lamaze Method was
introduced to France by Dr Fernand Lamaze. In 1960, Karmel and Elisabeth Bing
founded the American Society for Psychoprophylaxis (ASPO), now known as Lamaze
International. Lamaze’s clinic in Paris: conscious relaxation and controlled breathing
to manage the pain of contractions, avoiding the need for drugs.[1] Expecting mother wants to see a
little bundle of the job by giving birth to a child. The fear and anxiety about
childbirth often prevent most women from enjoying the experience, however,
adequate knowledge about signs of labour and delivery, in general, can create
feelings of confidence and a sense of well-being, which is very crucial in
ensuring a successful labour and child birth.[2]
Normal labour occurs between 37-42
weeks of gestation. Accompanying the physical changes, the women may have
feelings of great intensity varying from exited anticipation to fearful
expectancy.[3] Increase in confidence Improved knowledge about how
they can cope and work during labour will help the woman to have a positive
childbirth. [4]
Lamaze is a method of
childbirth in which the expectant mother is prepared psychologically and
physically to give birth without the use of pain-relieving drugs. Lamaze
is a breathing technique used to help the pregnant mother to relax during
labour. Lamaze breathing is a coping mechanism that allows for decreasing the
perception of pain associated with delivery. In this Lamaze method women for safe, healthy birth by providing
current and evidence-based information given to the mothers.[5]
When the cervix is <5
cm dilated, contractions occur at 2-4 mts and last for 40-60 sec. The rate of
respiration is 10 or fewer breaths in a minute, increasing to 12/min as labour
intensifies. During the active part of the first stage of labour from the
active part of the first stage of labour, up to the second stage, the cervix is
5cm to nearly fully dilated as fast as once a second at the peak and slowly to
every 6 sec as the uterus relaxes. She is relaxing her perineal and vaginal
muscles, and to take a cleansing breath at the beginning and end of each
contraction.[6]
Lowe, (1996) stated that
confidence may be increased with the Lamaze method which provides detailed
information about childbirth, vicarious experiences and techniques to increase
coping ability during labour.[7]
Women in labour should be encouraged to trust
their instincts, and listen to their bodies. An increase in confidence has
associated with a lower level of pain experienced during labour. The Lamaze method of childbirth
includes a set of breathing exercises and we teach these exercises to staff
nurses. Teaching the knowledge about how they
can cope and work during labour will help the woman to have a positive
childbirth experience.[8]
MATERIALS
AND METHODS- A
pre-experimental design with one group pre-test, post-test without control
group design was used to assess the effectiveness of the video-assisted
teaching (VAT) programme on staff nurses' knowledge regarding the use of Lamaze
breathing exercise to ease the labour process during the first stage of
labour in selected hospitals of Bagalkot district. A Knowledge structured
questionnaire was administered and the data obtained was organized and analysed
by use of Descriptive and Inferential statistics.
Study
design-
The research design adopted for this study was a pre-experimental one-group
pre-test –post –test without control group design. Here one experimental group
of clients were selected with simple randomization and no control group is
used. A pre-test was conducted among staff nurses using a structured
questionnaire on Labour and Lamaze breathing exercises. The
intervention was given in the form of video-assisted teaching (VAT) programme
on knowledge regarding the use of Lamaze breathing exercises to ease the labour
process during the first stage of labour among staff nurses.
The
setting of the study Setting is the Physical location and conditions in which
data collection will occur. The present study was conducted in a selected
hospital Bagalkot. The study setting was selected according to the availability
of staff nurses working in the labour ward Bagalkot. Participants: A sample
consists of the subject of units that comprise the population for the present
study. In this study sample size is (n=50) staff nurses working in labour ward
in selected hospital Bagalkot.
Instruments- A structured closed-ended knowledge
questionnaire. Data was collected using Self Administration Questionnaire with
the use of a structured closed ended knowledge questionnaire. It consists of 40
knowledge items related to labour and knowledge questionnaires related to the
lamaze breathing exercise. These items were closed-ended, multiple-choice
questions. A seeking system is developed for the item each correct answer is
assigned a score of one wrong answer or a score of zero. The total score is 40.
Data
Collection Procedure- The
main study was conducted for 4 weeks between 21/6/2022
to 14/7/2022 at Hanagal Shri kumareshwar hospital and Research Centre,
Navanagar, Bagalkot, Daddenavar hospital Bagalkot and Shirur multispeciality
hospital Bagalkot, India.
Variables
of the study- Dependent
variable: In this study, it refers to the knowledge regarding the use of
Lamaze breathing exercises among staff nurses. Independent variable: video-assisted
teaching programme on knowledge regarding the use of Lamaze breathing exercises
among staff nurses.
Statistical
Analysis- The
data was analysed using SPSS 18 statistical package. Numerical data obtained
from the sample was organized and summarized with the help of descriptive
statistics like percentage mean, and standard deviation. Association between
post-test knowledge score of staff nurses. Working in labour wards in selected hospitals
Bagalkot and Chi-square tests were used to analyze the association of knowledge
with socio-demographic variables.
Ethical
Consideration- Ethical
clearance certificate was obtained from B.V.V.S Sajjalashree Institute of
Nursing Sciences, the institutional ethical committee. Written consent was
obtained from each participant.
RESULTS
Socio-demographic characteristics of staff
nurses-
Percentage-wise distribution of staff nurses according to their age groups reveals
that out of 50 subjects, a higher percentage (62%) of staff nurse are in the
age group of 21-25 years, (24%) of the staff nurses are in the age of
26-30years only (14%) of the staff nurses age in the age group of 31-35years, The
highest percentage (62%) of staff nurses in the age group of 21-25 years. Percentage-wise
distribution of staff nurses according to their educational status shows that
the highest percentage (80%) of staff nurses have studied Diploma in nursing,
(10%) of staff nurses have studied BSc nursing, (10%) of staff nurses have
studied Post basic BSc nursing. It shows that the majority of staff nurses have
studied Diploma in nursing. Percentage-wise distribution of staff nurses
according to their no of habitual residents reveals that out of 50 staff
nurses, the highest percentage (82%) of staff nurses are living in an urban
area, and only (18%) of staff nurses are living in a rural area. The highest
percentage (82%) of staff nurses are living in an urban area. Percentage-wise
distribution of staff nurses according to their professional experience reveals
that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest percentage (70%) of staff nurses in
the experience group of 1-3 years, (18%) of staff nurses in the experience
group of 4-6years, (12%) in the experience group of 7-9years. The highest
percentage (70%) of staff nurses in the experience group of 1-3 years.
Percentage-wise distribution of staff nurses according to their professional
experience reveals that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest percentage (88%) of
staff nurses in the experience was gained private hospital, only (10%) of staff
nurses in the experience gained in Govt hospital, (2%) staff nurses in the
experience was gained in community primary health centres. The highest
percentage (90%) of staff nurses in the experience was gained in a private
hospital. Percentage-wise distribution of staff nurses according to their
experience in the labour word reveals that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest
percentage (86%) of staff nurses had experience in a labour ward of 1-3year,
(14%) a percentage of staff nurses had experience in labour ward of 4-6years,
and (10%) of staff nurses had experience in labour ward of 7-9 years, only (4%)
had the experience in the labour ward. It reveals that the highest percentage
(86%) of staff nurses the experience in the labour ward. Percentage-wise
distribution of staff nurses according to their in-service education program
reveals that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest percentage (92%) of staff
nurses is not attending in-service education program. Only (8%) of staff nurses
have attended in-service education programmes (Table 1).
Table 1: Distribution of cases and controls
according to their socio-demographic characteristics
Socio-demo
graphic factors |
Character |
Frequency
(f) |
Percentage
(%) |
|
1 |
Age |
21-25Y 26-30Y 31-35Y |
31 12 7 |
62 24 14 |
2 |
Religion |
Hindu Muslim Christian Other |
40 6 4 0 |
80 12 8 0 |
3 |
Type
of family |
Nuclear
family Joint
family Extended
family Single
parent |
45 5 0 0 |
90 10 0 0 |
4 |
Educational
Qualification |
Diploma
in Nursing BSc
Nursing Post-basic
BSc nursing Any
other |
40 5 5 0 |
80 10 10 0 |
5 |
Habitual
residence |
Rural Urban |
9 41 |
18 82 |
6 |
Professional
experience |
1-3Y 4-6Y 7-9Y |
35 9 6 |
70 18 12 |
7 |
Institution,
where experience was gained |
Govt
hospital Private
hospital Community
primary health centres |
5 43 2 |
10 86 4 |
8 |
Family
monthly income |
Below
5000/M 5001-10,000/M 10,001-20,000/M More
than 20,000/M |
0 41 6 3 |
0 82 12 6 |
9 |
Source
of information |
Electronic
media TV New
media (mobile and internet) Peer
group and social group Health
professionals |
0 40 5 5 |
0 80 10 10 |
10 |
Experience
in the labour ward |
1-3Y 4-6Y 7-9Y More
than 10yrs |
43 7 5 2 |
86 14 10 4 |
11 |
In-service
education programme |
Yes No |
4 46 |
8 92 |
M=
Month, Y= Years
Comparison of the knowledge level of staff nurses in
pre-test and post-test - Knowledge-wise comparison of staff
nurses in pre-test reveals the following results. In the pre-test, out of 50
staff nurses, the highest percentage 78% of staff nurses had poor knowledge,
16% of staff nurses had average knowledge, followed by lowest percentage 6% of
a staff nurse with very poor knowledge None of the staff nurses had excellent
and good knowledge labour and Lamaze breathing exercise. Percentage-wise
distribution of staff nurses working in the labour ward in the post-test
reveals that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest post-test (40%) of staff noses
had good knowledge, (30%) had excellent knowledge followed percentage (30%) of
staff nurses with average knowledge. None of the staff nurses had excellent and
good knowledge regarding labour and Lamaze breathing exercise, excellent and
good knowledge regarding labour and Lamaze breathing exercise (Table 2, Fig. 1).
Table 2:
Percentage-wise distribution of staff nurses to a level of knowledge in
pre-test and post-test (N=50)
|
Pre-test |
Post-test |
||
No
of respondents |
Percentage
(%) |
No
respondents |
Percentage (%) |
|
Excellent |
0 |
0 |
15 |
30 |
Good |
0 |
0 |
20 |
40 |
Average |
8 |
16 |
15 |
30 |
Poor |
39 |
78 |
0 |
0 |
Very poor |
3 |
6 |
0 |
0 |
Total |
50 |
100 |
50 |
100 |
Fig. 1: Percentage-wise distribution of staff
nurses to a level of knowledge in pre-test and post-test
Area-wise means, SD and mean percentage of
the knowledge score in pre-test and post-test- Area-wise comparison of the mean and
standard deviation of the knowledge score of the pre-test and post-test reveals
an increase in the mean knowledge score of the staff nurses after the video-assisted
teaching programme. A comparison of the mean percentage of the knowledge score
in the pre-test and post-test reveals an increase of (44.5%) percentage in the
mean knowledge score of the staff nurses after assisted teaching programme. Comparison of area-wise mean and SD of the knowledge score
in the area of knowledge questionnaires on labour "shows that the
post-test mean of knowledge score in this area was 15.1 with SD±2.80058, which
was 77.2 % of the total score. Whereas the pre-test mean knowledge score was
7.16 with SD±2.5663 which was 38.5% of the total score. The effectiveness of
VATP in this area was a mean knowledge score of 8.28 with SD ± 0.23428 which
was 41.4% of the total score. The area of knowledge
regarding knowledge questionnaires related to the Lamaze breathing exercise
shows that the post-test mean knowledge score was 15.1 with SD±2.86606, which
was 75.5% of the total score. Whereas, the pre-test mean knowledge score was
6.2 with SD±2.0503, which was 31% of the total score. The effectiveness of VATP
in this area was mean 8.9 knowledge score of SD±0.81576 which was (44.5%) of
the total score. The overall findings reveal that the
post-test knowledge score (30.54±5.66), which was (72.88%) of the total score
was more when compared to the pre-test knowledge score (13±4.61), which was
(36.05%) total score. The effectiveness of VATP in this area was a mean
knowledge score of 17 with SD±1.04, which was (36.83%) of the total score. Hence it indicates that the VATP was
effective in enhancing the knowledge of staff nurses. (Table 3).
Table 3: Area-wise
mean, SD and mean percentage of the knowledge score in pre-test and post-test (N=50)
Knowledge area |
Max. Score |
Pre-test (01) |
Post-test (02) |
Effectiveness (02-01) |
|||
Mean±SD |
Mean(%) |
Mean± SD |
Mean(%) |
Mean±SD |
Mean(%) |
||
Knowledge questionnaires on
Labour |
20 |
7.16±2.5663 |
38.5 |
15.44±2.80058 |
77.2 |
8.28±0.23428 |
41.4 |
Knowledge questionnaires related
to Lamaze breathing exercise |
20 |
6.2±2.0503 |
31 |
15.1±
2.86606 |
75.5 |
8.9±0.81576 |
44.5 |
Total |
40 |
13±4.61 |
36.05 |
30.54±5.66 |
72.88 |
17±1.04 |
36.83 |
Significant
difference between the pre-test knowledge and post-test knowledge score of
staff nurses working in selected hospital Bagalkot- As the calculated ‘t’ value (17.77) was much higher than
table valve (1.96) for the degree of freedom 49 and 0.05% level of significance
(Table 4).
Table
4: Significant
difference between the pre-test knowledge and post-test knowledge score of
staff nurses
working in selected hospital Bagalkot
Mean |
Mean Diff |
SD Diff |
Paired t-value |
Table value |
|
Pre-test |
13.36 |
17.12 |
0.95 |
17.77 |
1.96 |
Post-test |
30.48 |
Association
between post-test knowledge score of staff nurses working in selected hospital
Bagalkot- Chi-square value is lesser than table value for
socio-demographic variables Age (ᵡ2=0.898814, p=0.05)
Religion (ᵡ2=0.232414, p=0.05) Type of family (ᵡ2=0.272681,
p=0.05) Educational qualification (ᵡ2=0.507387, p=0.05)
Residence (ᵡ2=0.772822, p=0.05) Professional experience (ᵡ2=0.84873,
p=0.05), Institution where the experience was gained (ᵡ2=0.428237,
p=0.05), Monthly family income (ᵡ2=0.333906, p=0.05)
Source of information (ᵡ2= 0.507387, p=0.05),
Experience in labour ward (ᵡ2=0.351732, p=0.05), Have
attended in-service education programme (ᵡ2=0.313659, p=0.05)
(Table 5).
Table 5: Association
between post-test knowledge score of staff nurses working in selected hospital
Bagalkot (N=50)
Socio-demographic
variables |
DF |
Chi-square-valve |
Table value |
P-value |
Association |
|
1 |
Age |
1 |
0.898814 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
2 |
Religion |
1 |
0.232414 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
3 |
Type of family |
1 |
0.272681 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
4 |
Educational Qualification |
1 |
0.507387 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
5 |
Residence |
1 |
0.772822 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
6 |
Professional experience |
1 |
0.84873 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
7 |
Institution, where experience was
gained |
1 |
0.428237 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
8 |
Monthly family income |
1 |
0.333906 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
9 |
Source of information |
1 |
0.507387 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
10 |
Experience in labour ward |
1 |
0.351732 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
11 |
Have attended in-service education
programme |
1 |
0.313659 |
1.96 |
0.05 |
NS |
DISCUSSION- The
present study was conducted to find out the video-assisted teaching programme
on Lamaze breathing exercises among staff nurses. Attending the
selected hospital Bagalkot. To achieve the objectives of the study, the
pre-experimental research design was adopted. A sample of 50 staff nurses was
selected using a disproportional stratified random technique.
The present study shows
that most staff nurses according to their age groups reveals that out of 50
subjects, a higher percentage (62%) of staff nurses are in the age group of
21-25 years, (24%) of the staff nurses are in the age of 26-30years only (14%)
of the staff nurses age in the age group of 31-35years, The highest percentage
(62%) of staff nurses in the age group of 21-25 years.
An experimental study was
conducted on the effectiveness of Video-assisted Teaching on the Knowledge of
Staff Nurses regarding Lamaze Breathing Exercises during the First Stage of
labour among Primi Parturient Mothers in Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India. They
have selected 60 staff nurses. The tools used for conducting the study included
demographic data and a self-structured questionnaire to assess the knowledge of
both groups. The study results show that It is observed, that in the
experimental group, a majority of staff nurses (13 (43.33%) belonged between
21-25 years of age, 12 (40%) were between 26-30 years of age, and 5 (16.66%)
staff nurses belonged to 31-35 years of age group a majority of staff nurses
(18 (60%) belonged to 21-25 years of age, 10 (33.33%) were between 26-30 years
of age and 2 (6.66%) staff nurses belonged to 31-35 years of age group the
experimental group, a majority of the staff nurses (19 (63.33%) had 1-3 years
of professional experience, 8 (26.66%) staff nurses had 4-6 years of
experience, and 3 (10%) staff nurses had 7-9 years of professional experience.
In the control group, most of the staff nurses (21 (70%)) had 1-3 years of
professional experience, 5 (16.66%) staff nurses had 4-6 years of professional
experience, and 4 (13.33%) staff nurses had 7-9 years of professional
experience. Hence, we should include video-assisted teaching to promote
knowledge on the subject among staff nurses. [9]
Most staff nurses
according to their Type of family reveals that out of 50 staff nurses, the
highest percentage (90%) of staff nurses have nuclear, (10%), staff nurses have
joint, (0%) staff nurses have extended family, and only (0%) staff nurses have
a single parent. The highest percentage90% of staff nurses belong to the
nuclear family.
The present study's
majority of their educational status shows that the highest percentage (80%) of
staff nurses have studied Diploma in nursing, (10%) of staff nurses have
studied BSc nursing, (10%) staff nurses have studied Post basic BSc nursing. It
shows that the majority of staff nurses have studied Diploma in nursing.
A semi-prospective case-control study was
conducted to assess the evidence-based research studies supporting the use of
Lamaze breathing exercises for childbirth preparation at Aberdare District
Maternity Unit, Mid Glamorgan, and Wales in 2011, among One hundred twenty-six
primigravida women. The
results show that the mean lengths of the first stage of labour in the
primigravida women were 6.4 h after hypnosis and 9.3 h in the control group (p<0.0001);
the mean lengths of the second stage were 37 min and 50 min, respectively (p<0.001).
In the multi-parous women, the corresponding values were 5.3 h and 6.2 h (p<0.01);
and 24 and 22 min (ns). The use of analgesic agents was significantly
reduced (p<0.001)
in both hypnotized groups compared with their controls. The study concluded that
in addition to demonstrating the
benefits of hypnotherapy, the study gives some insight into the relative
proportions of mechanical and psychological components involved in the longer
duration of labour in primigravida women. The hypnotized groups had a reduction
in the duration of both the first and second stages of labour.[10]
Many staff nurses work in
labour wards in selected hospitals in Bagalkot. their knowledge of habitual
residence reveals that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest percentage (82%) of
staff nurses are living in an urban area, only (18%) of staff nurses are living
in the rural area. The highest percentage (82%) of staff nurses are living in
an urban area. A quasi-experimental study was conducted in India to evaluate the
effectiveness of slow-paced breathing on pain perception during the first stage
of labour among primipara mothers. Slow-paced breathing was taught to the
experimental group before the labour pain started which they practised during
labour. Pain perception level was measured using a pain intensity scale and
facial pain scale. The investigator concluded that mothers who practised
slow-paced breathing reported a significant reduction in pain perception. The
mean value of 4.28 in the experimental group and 6.22 in the control group
using the pain intensity scale. The computed t‟ value of 6.35 reveals
that slow-paced breathing is effective at 5% level of significance.[11]
A study on the efficiency of
massage therapy and breathing techniques on pain intensity and physiological
responses to labour pain. The researcher took 40 primi gravida mothers,
satisfying the inclusion criteria were selected and randomly divided for massage
and breathing techniques. The pain intensity is measured by a numerical pain
intensity scale. The study concluded that both techniques are effective in
labour pain relief and decrease the caesarean section rate. [12]
The present study shows
that according to their professional experience reveals that out of 50 staff
nurses, the highest percentage (70%) of staff nurses in the experience group of
1-3 years, (18%) of staff nurses in the experience group of 4-6years, (12%) in
the experience group of 7-9years. The highest percentage (70%) of staff nurses
in the experience group of 1-3 years.
A true experimental study has conducted the Effectiveness of a Planned Teaching
Programme on Lamaze Technique in terms of Knowledge and Skill of Staff Nurses
Working in the Antenatal Ward and Labour Room in a Maternity Hospital in
Kashmir they have selected 50 staff nurses working in the labor
room selected by simple random technique. The researcher has
collected the data -
The structured knowledge questionnaire of the Planned teaching programme.
Majority of the
subjects (20) 66.6% had an experience of more than 10 years, (5) 16.6% had the
experience of 7-9 years, (4) 13.3% had an experience of 4-6 years and only (1)
3.30% had an experience of 1-3 years. (9)30% of sample subjects had an
experience of 7-9 years, (9) 30% had an experience of 4-6 years, (9) 30 % had
an experience of 1-3 years and only (3) 10% had more than 10 years of
experience in the antenatal ward and labour room. Nurse educators need to organize
short-term training programmes or workshops on the Lamaze technique for the
staff nurses working in the antenatal ward and labour room.[13]
Jhala [14] conducted
a descriptive study to evaluate the intensity of the labour pain at the two
stages of cervical dilatation, (cervical dilation of 2-5cm and 6-10 cm) at East
Cardinal University, school of nursing, Greenville, 78 women in labour were
selected through convenient sampling technique. Using 3 self-reported measures
such as VAS, present pain intensity scale and MC Gill pain questionnaire
carried out the pain assessment. These were the one observational measure to
rate the behavioral index of pain. The data were analysed by descriptive and
inferential statistics. The result of the study shows that when cervical
dilation increased, there was a significant increase in self-report pain and
observed pain on all the cited measures (t=15.72, p=0.01). The pain was
characterized as discomforting during early dilation and distressing horrible
and excruciating as dilatation progressed.[14]
In the present study
majority of staff nurses according to their professional experience reveals
that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest percentage (88%) of staff nurses in
the experience was gained private hospital, only (10%) of staff nurses in the
experience was gained in Govt hospital, (2%) staff nurses in the experience was
gained in community primary health centres. The highest percentage (90%) of
staff nurses in the experience was gained in a private hospital.
Kaur
and Rana [15] conducted
a quasi-experimental study to assess the effect of video on breathing exercises
among staff nurses. 40 samples were purposely selected, were randomly allocated
20 each into experimental and control groups. A self-constricted structure
questionary was used to collect the data. The study concluded that breathing
exercises were found to be an effective effectiveness of video among staff
nurses. [15]
Percentage-wise
distribution of staff nurses according to their family monthly income reveals
that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest percentage (82%) of staff nurses are
getting 5001-10,000 monthly income, only (12%) of staff nurses are getting
10,001-20,000 monthly incomes, (6%) of staff nurses are getting more than
20,000 monthly incomes, (0%) staff nurses getting below 5000 monthly income. It
reveals that the majority (82%) of staff nurses are working in the labour ward
in selected hospitals in Bagalkot their family income is 5001-10,000 monthly
income. In most staff nurses according to their source of information reveal
that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest percentage (80%) of staff nurses had a
source of information through media mobile and the internet, (10%) a percentage
of staff nurses had information through friends and social group, and (10%) of
staff nurses had information through a health professional, 0% had the
information through TV. It reveals that the majority (80%) of staff nurses
under the study had higher sources of information through new media, mobile and
the internet.
Percentage-wise
distribution of staff nurses according to their experience in the labour word
reveals that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest percentage (86 %) of staff nurses
had experience in labour ward for 1-3year, (14%) a percentage of staff nurses
had experience in labour ward of 4-6years, and (10%) of staff nurses had
experience in labour ward of 7-9years, only (4%) had the experience in the
labour ward. It reveals that the highest percentage (86%) of staff nurses the
experience in the labour ward. In most staff nurses according to their
in-service education program reveal that out of 50 staff nurses, the highest
percentage (92%) of staff nurses is not attending in-service education
programs. Only (8%) of staff nurses have attended in-service education
programmes.
A study to evaluate the
effectiveness of guided training in Lamaze breathing exercises among staff
nurses. The investigator used a non-probability purposive sampling technique
for the selection of samples 60 in the experimental group. The tool used
self-structured questionnaires. The
study revealed that there was a high significant difference between the
pre-test and post-test at p<0.001. Hence, the study concluded that more
effective guidance and training to improve knowledge regarding Lamaze breathing
exercises in staff nurses.[16]
Experimental research was
conducted to assess the effectiveness of Lamaze breathing techniques on labour
pain and anxiety The study was conducted at the Community Health centre, kolar
road, Bhopal (M.P.) have selected 60 primigravida mothers. for the present
study by following simple random techniques, the researcher has collected the
data in the interview method. by use of a pain perception scale, and an
observational rating scale for performing Lamaze breathing. The results of the
study mean of the control group are 7.55 and of the experimental group are 4.55,
mean percent is 75.5% and 45.5% of the control and experimental group
respectively and, SD of the control group is 0.945 and for the experimental
group, it is 1.234. The 't' value is 3.96 and the P-value is p<0.001
which is highly significant. The study has concluded that Continuous ongoing
assessment helped to evaluate the performance of breathing exercises during pregnancy
and labour. The practice of breathing exercises shortens the duration of labour
and prevents complications during labour. [17]
The present study shows that
knowledge regarding knowledge questionnaires related to the Lamaze breathing
exercise shows that the post-test mean knowledge score was 15.1 with SD±2.86606,
which was 75.5% of the total score. Whereas the pre-test means knowledge score
was 6.2 with SD±2.0503, which was 31% of the total score. The effectiveness of
VATP in this area was mean 8.9 knowledge score of SD±0.81576, which was (44.5%)
of the total score. A quasi-experimental study was
conducted in Thailand to determine the effect of childbirth preparation on
fear, labour pain, coping behaviour and
childbirth satisfaction among 60 primi Para women. In
the control group, 30 subjects received only routine care from staff nurses and
30 subjects in the experimental group received routine care plus childbirth
preparation classes. Results revealed that the primiparas in
the experimental group had better labour pain
coping behaviour (16.37) than those in the control group (15.18). The study
also showed that childbirth satisfaction was (82.77) in the experimental group
and was higher than those in the control group (76.03).[18]
In many post-test knowledge
scores (30.54±5.66), which was (72.88%) of the total score was more when
compared to the pre-test knowledge score (13±4.61), which was (36.05%) total
score. The effectiveness of VATP in this area was a mean knowledge score of 17
with SD±1.04 which was (36.83%) of the total score. Hence it indicates that the
VATP was effective in enhancing the knowledge of staff nurses.
Thomas and Dhiwar [19]
conducted a study on the effectiveness of patterned breathing exercises
in pain reduction during first stage of labour in Pune city. The study design
used was a non-equivalent pre-test post-test control group design. A numeric
pain intensity scale was used to assess the pain. In the active phase of labour
patients is selected and instructed to practice patterned breathing for the
experimental group. A pre-test was assessed on admission and a post-test was
assessed every hour 5 times. The study concluded that the mean post-test score
of the experimental groups was lower than the control group. Hence, it is
effective in the reduction of labour pain perception.[19]
Varalakshmi et al.
[20] shows that the Chi-square value is lesser than the table value
for socio-demographic variables, age (ᵡ2=0.688702, p=0.05),
religion (ᵡ2=0.831871, p=0.05), type of family (ᵡ2=0.705857,
p=0.05), educational qualification (ᵡ2=0.390008, p=0.05)
Residence(ᵡ2=0.1712795, p=0.05), professional
experience (ᵡ2=0.851205, p=0.05), an institution where
the experience was gained (ᵡ2=0.7773, p=0.05), monthly
family income (ᵡ2= 0.4624, p=0.05), source of
information (ᵡ2= 0.288844, p=0.05), experience in
labour ward (ᵡ2=0.8231, p=0.05), have attended
in-service education programme (ᵡ2=0.863771, p=0.05).
The quasi-experimental
design was used selected to assess the effectiveness of the Lamaze breathing
exercise on labour pain and anxiety. The study was conducted among 120 samples
of primi mothers, 60 each in experimental and control groups. The purposive
sample technique was used for selecting the sample. Data were collected from
the subject using a numerical rating scale. The experimental group was given
Lamaze breathing exercises for 10 days. The results reveal that the calculated
t value for the experimental group is t=27.4746, which is found to be
significant at p>0.05 level and the t value for the control group is
t=5. 7930, which is found to be significant at p>0.05, so, Lamaze
breathing on labour pain among primiparous mothers. The results reveal that the
calculated t value for the experimental group is t=16.7042, which is found to
be significant at p>0.05 level and the t value for the control group
is t=9.5537, which is found to be significant at p>0.05, so, the
effectiveness of Lamaze breathing on labour anxiety. [20]
Future research can
investigate the effect of various methods to reduce labour pain to improve the
confidence level of mothers.
Contribution
of authors
Research concept
- Shruti Maddur, Jayashri Awarasang
Research
design- Shruti Maddur, Jayashri Awarasang
Supervision-
Shruti Maddur, Dr Deelip Somaninga Nateker
Data
collection- Shruti Maddur.
Data
analysis and interpretation- Shruti Maddur
Literature
search- Shruti Maddur
Writing
article- Shruti Maddur
Critical
review- Jayashri Awarasang, Dr Deelip Somaninga
Nateker
Article
editing- Shruti Maddur, Jayashri Awarasang, Dr Deelip Somaninga
Nateker
Final
approval- Jayashri Awarasang, Dr Deelip Somaninga
Nateker
REFERENCES
1.
Declercq
ER, Sakala C, Corry MP, Applebaum S. Listening to Mothers II: Report of
the second national U.S. survey of women’s childbearing experiences. New
York, NY: Childbirth Connection, 2006.
2.
Skilled
birth attendance (SBA). A handbook for Auxiliary Nurse Midwives, Lady Health
Visitor and staff Nurses. Ministry of health and family welfare Government of
India, 2010.
3. Lagos
A. International journal of advanced scientific research. Available at:
http://www.newresearchjournal.com/scientific, 2008.
5.
Latha P. Various methods of labor and
Lamaze technique. Ind J Nurs Midwif Res Summer, 2014; 12(3): 111.
6.
Hodnett ED. Pain and women’s satisfaction
with the experience of childbirth. A systematic review. Am J Obstet Gynecol.,
2002: (5): 160-72.
7.
Ian D. Practical obstetric problem, 5th
edition, B.I Publications, New Delhi, 1996.
8.
Dickson
SK. Maternal-infant nursing care, 3rd Ed. Mosby
publications. Misouri., 1998; pp. 261-73.
9.
Nagvanshi S, Linson CC. Effect of
Video-assisted Teaching on Knowledge of Staff Nurses regarding Lamaze Breathing
Exercises during the First Stage of Labour to Improve Maternal and Foetal
Outcome among Primi Parturient Mothers. Ind J Holist Nurs., 2020; 11(4): 12-18.
10. Singh
A, Pradhan SK. A descriptive survey approach was used to assess the knowledge
and attitude of health professionals regarding lamaze method. OBG and Paediatric
Departments at M.S. Ramaiah Hospitals, Bangalore, 2007; 37(4): 519-28.
11. Brown
ST, Douglas C. Study on women’s evaluation of intrapartum non-pharmacological
pain relief methods during labour. J Perinat Educ Adv Normal birth, 2001;
10(3): 1-8.
12.
Tournaire M, Theau-Yonneau A.
Complementary and Alternative approaches to pain relief during labour. Evid
Based Complement Alternat Med., 2007; 4(4): 409-17. doi: 10.1093/ecam/nem012.
13. Irshad
T, Chhugani M, Tamang EL. Measuring the Effectiveness of Planned Teaching
Programme on Lamaze Technique in terms of Knowledge and Skill of Staff Nurses
Working in Antenatal Ward and Labour Room in a Maternity Hospital of Kashmir.
Int J Sci Res., 2016; 5(1): 1981-85.
14.
Jhala AK.
A Study to Assess the Effectiveness of Lamaze Breathing on Labor Pain
and Anxiety Towards Labor Outcome among Primigravida Mothers During Labor in
Community Health Center, Kolar Road, Bhopal (M.P.). Ind J Obstet Gynecol.,
2017; 5(1): 19-22.
15.
Kaur K, Rana A. Assess the effect of video
on breathing exercises during labour pain perception. Nurs Midwif Res J, 2013;
9(1): 41-44.
16. Rajakumari
A. Effectiveness of guided imaginary in pain perception and anxiety, Inter J
Sci Res., 2015; 4(5): 809-11.
17. Declercq ER,
Sakala C, Corry MP, Applebaum S. Listening to Mothers II: Report of the
second national U.S. survey of women’s childbearing experiences. New
York, NY: Childbirth Connection, 2006.
18. Reidmann GL. The
Global Library of Women’s Medicine’s. Welfare of Women. Education for
childbirth: Nurse- midwife, female health association, 2008. Available
at:
https://www.glowm.com/section-view/heading/Education%20for%20Childbirth/item/109.
doi:
10.3843/GLOWM.10109.
19.
Thomas ME, Dhiwar MS. Effectiveness of
Patterned Breathing Technique in Reduction of Pain During First Stage of Labour
Among Primigravidas. Sinhgad e-J Nurs., 2011; I(Ii):6–8.
20.
Varalakshmi E. A study to assess the
effectiveness of lamaze breathing exercise on labour pain and anxiety towards
the outcome among primiparous mothers in government Head Quarters Hospital,
Thiruvallur, 2019; 8(8): 1-2.