Research Article (Open access) |
---|
SSR Inst. Int. J. Life Sci., 7(1):
2953-2961,
January 2021
Role of Ki-67
and Argyrophilic Nucleolar Organiser Region (AgNoR) Counts in Squamous Cell
Carcinoma
Neelima
Verma1, Suman Lata Verma2, Shadab Ahmad3*, Neena Gupta4
1Professor,
Department of Pathology, GSVM Medical College Kanpur, India
2Professor and
Head, Department of Pathology, GSVM Medical College, Kanpur, India
3Junior Resident,
Department of Pathology, GSVM Medical College Kanpur, India
4Professor,
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, GSVM Medical College Kanpur, India
*Address for Correspondence: Dr. Shadab
Ahmad, Junior Resident, Department of Pathology, G. S. V. M. Medical College,
Kanpur, India
E-mail: shadab1005ansari@gmail.com
ABSTRACT- Background: Squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix is the most common subtype of
cervical cancer and it usually accounts for 80-90% of the cases. These
carcinomas mostly grow at the squamocolumnar junction (SCJ). The tumour tends
to grow outward showing an exophytic growth especially at the squamocolumnar
junction outside the external uterine wall whereas cancer tends to grow along
the cervical canal showing an endophytic growth pattern where the SCJ is
located within the cervical canal. This study has experimentally shown the role
of AgNOR and Ki-67 scores in tumour proliferation.
Methods: Cervical specimens were obtained and prepared in a specified fashion as
described. The samples were de-waxed and staining was done with AgNOR. Then,
the AgNOR was counted and scoring was done. Again, the samples were also
stained with Ki-67.
Results: This study has included 235 cases from the Department of Pathology of
Ganesh Shankar Vidyarthi Memorial Medical College, Kanpur, India. The mean
value of AgNOR count in the Control group came to be 10.62±0.45 while the mean
AgNOR count was found to be 10.62±0.45, 15.10±0.79, 18.39±0.67, 19.75±0.74 and
19.59±0.59 for in-Situ SCC, well-differentiated SCC, moderately differentiated
SCC, poorly differentiated SCC, SCC with basaloid differentiation,
respectively.
Conclusion: The study confirmed that AgNOR count increases with a higher grade of
malignancy. It was concluded that AgNOR and Ki-67 scores can be used as an
efficient predictor of tumour proliferation.
Keywords- AGNOR, Cervical carcinoma, in-Situ SCC, Ki-67,
Squamouscell carcinoma
INTRODUCTION- Squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix is the most
common subtype of cervical cancer [1] and it usually accounts for
80-90% of the cases [2]. These carcinomas mostly grow at the
squamocolumnar junction (SCJ) [1]. The tumour tends to grow outward
showing an exophytic growth pattern in younger women where the squamocolumnar
junction is located outside the external uterine wall, whereas cancer tends to
grow along the cervical canal showing an endophytic growth pattern, where the
SCJ is located within the cervical canal. Most tumours arise from a
pre-cancerous disease called high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL).
Most of these carcinomas are a result of the normal squamous cells in the
cervix becoming infected with a high-risk type of virus called the human
papillomavirus (HPV) [3,4]. Various investigations of the study of
disease transmission of cervical malignant tumours have shown a solid
relationship with, conjugal and sexual patterns. Even though it is grounded
that women with numerous accomplices and early ages at first intercourses are
in high danger, though less information is known regarding how these factors
have their effects. Recent examinations reveal that steady partners and
frequent intercourse may further enhance the risk, supporting hypotheses
regarding a vulnerable period of the cervix and a requirement for rehashed
openness to an infectious agent. It is currently broadly acknowledged that HPV
is a major infectious etiological agent. Other risk factors for cervical
malignant growth include cigarette smoking, oral contraceptive use, and certain
malnutrition. Recent investigations have shown that there is a need to
highlight not only the female factor but also the male factor. To conclude
this, genetic factors, bacterial infections, viral infections, smoking, and
sexual habits are some of the known risk factors [4,5].
Ki-67 is broadly used in the routine
pathological investigation as a proliferation marker as its expression is
strongly associated with tumor cell proliferation and growth [6].
The assessment of the biopsies from the cancer patients is known to be
established with nuclear protein Ki-67 [7]. It has been clinically
displayed to relate with metastasis and clinical phases of cancer. The Ki-67
marking index is an autonomous prognostic component for survival rate, which
incorporates all stages and grade classifications. The arrest of cell
proliferation has been achieved by blocking Ki-67 either by microinjection of
antibodies or through the use of antisense oligonucleotides [8]. The
number of nuclei staining positively for these markers of proliferation can be
estimated by simple counting or can be measured in an image analysis system. In
cervical intraepithelial neoplasia, both proliferating cell nuclear agent and
Ki-67 expressions are increased in the upper levels of the cervical epithelium
as compared to normal cervices [9]. And therefore it is thought that
this staining technique especially Ki-67 might be very helpful in
distinguishing cervical intraepithelial neoplasia from non-neoplastic lesions.
Expanding proof shows that Ki76 might be a viable objective in disease
treatment [10].
Nucleolar organizer regions are
described as nucleolar components which contain a set of argyrophilic proteins,
preferentially stained by silver methods. After the process of staining, these
NORs can be easily recognized as black dots throughout the nucleolar area. This
occurs due to a group of nucleolar proteins which have a high affinity for
silver (AgNOR proteins) [11]. The AgNOR method has been applied in
tumor pathology for both diagnostic and prognostic purposes for the past 12
years. These proteins accumulate highly in proliferating cells whereas their
expression is very low in non-proliferating cells [12]. Ki-67
immunostaining was known to be performed on 48 cases of squamous cell carcinoma
of the cervix and AgNOR silver staining on 29 cases. Though no correlation was
found between the method of staining and tumor stages, they correlated on a
histological level. The presence of a high Ki-67 score but not a high AgNOR
count was linked to early recurrence [13].
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study type and Source of data- The type of study is Retrospective
Cohort. The samples and data were obtained from G.S.V.M. Medical College,
Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh, India. This study included retrospective cases from
March 2019 to August 2021.
Sample collection and preparation- The cervical
biopsies or hysterectomy specimens were collected from the Department of
Pathology, G.S.V.M. medical college,
Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh. Fixation of cervical biopsies or
hysterectomy specimens was performed with buffered formalin. A complete gross
examination of the cervical biopsy and hysterectomy specimen was completed,
including a look at the cut surface as well as the outer surface of the tissue.
In histology biopsy tissue, tissue pieces were processed as a whole; in
hysterectomy specimens, tissues were sectioned and processed as two lips of the
cervix.
Inclusion criteria- The patients, who were enrolled in
G.S.V.M. medical college, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh and were suspected of cervical
carcinoma. The control group was selected from random patients, whose cervical
biopsy was done.
Exclusion criteria- The patients who discontinued their
management in G.S.V.M. medical college. The patients whose, AgNOR staining
score came to be either 0 or 1.
Procedure for processing tissue- The
tissue was placed in an automatic tissue processor. On Day 1, different
percentages of alcohol are taken and processed for around 2 hours to obtain the
outcome. On Day 2, different materials like alcohol, xylene, and wax are used
in this procedure and are processed for around two hours to obtain the final
result. On Day 3, a thermostatically controlled water bath was used in which
the cassettes were left for 15 minutes. From paraffin blocks, microtomes were
used to cut sections of four microns thickness. These cut sections were then
placed on a hot plate at a temperature of 65 degrees centigrade. After this,
the sections were stained with routinely used H and E stain. Hematoxylin and
Eosin stains are used for staining the sections.
To
make a hematoxylin solution, you need alcohol, distilled water, mercuric oxide,
hematoxylin, potassium alum or sodium iodate, and glacial acetic acid in
certain amounts. The sections are stained for 30 seconds in 1% eosin. After
staining the sections are washed for 1-5 minutes under tap water. They are then
dehydrated by alcohol, xylene is used for clearing the section, and then the
sections are mounted on DPX. Staining the section resulted in Black or blue
colored nuclei, shades of pink in the cytoplasm, red or orange colored RBC.
Staining of AgNOR- The
paraffin wax of 4 microns thickness section that is fixed with formalin is used
for the staining procedure. Xylene was used for the deparaffinization of the
sections. After that, the section was treated with absolute alcohol. The
sections were then put in a mixture of 1:3 ratio of acetic acid and alcohol for
nearly 5 minutes. The solution was then put in absolute alcohol. Then they are
dipped in 80% and 70% of graded alcohol respectively. After they are dipped in
alcohol they are washed in distilled water for about 5 minutes. The sections
are then kept for incubation in a freshly prepared working solution. They are
then washed for nearly 5 minutes under distilled water. Finally, the sections
are dehydrated in absolute alcohol. The sections are then cleared with xylene.
After that, they are mounted in DPX. Lastly, AgNOR was stained with Dark brown
or black dots while the background was yellow stained.
Counting of AgNOR- A
representative area is selected by examining the stained sections under a
low-power microscope. An oil immersion lens of 100x and an eyepiece of 10x is
used for counting AgNORs with a total magnification of 1000x.30 cells were
counted in every case and at last, a mean value is calculated. Under a
low-power microscope, the AgNORs are present as clusters that contain
discernible dots and they also contain individual satellites. The clusters that
contain discernible dots represent the nucleoli.
Parameters
used in AgNOR scoring- The
scores and their respective parameters are given below (Table 1).
Table 1: AgNOR staining and its score with parameters
Parameters |
score |
1.
Estimated number of AgNOR per cellLess than 2 2-5 More than 5 |
1 2 3 |
2.
Variation in the size and shape of satellite cell
(each scored)Uniform Moderate variation Marked variation |
1 2 3 |
3.
Variation in size and shape of the cluster (each
scored)Uniform Moderate variation Marked variation |
1 2 3 |
The mean value of each case is
calculated after counting the total number of AgNOR dots. Then the standard
deviations were calculated after obtaining the mean value of all the cases.
Staining
procedure of Ki-67- This procedure is completed in 3 steps.
The slide is pre-coated using a poly-L-Lysine a suitable adhesive, the
preparation of the immunostain and the preparation of chromogen.
Preparation
of reagents and buffer- Tris-buffer saline of 7.6 pH is
prepared in 750 ml of distilled water, 8.5 grams of sodium chloride, and 6.06
grams of tris (hydroxyl) methylamine as dissolved using 50% of HCl, the pH of
the solution is adjusted to 7.6. The final volume of the solution is then
adjusted to one liter. Citrate buffer 10 mM of pH 6. Stock solution A contains
0.1m of citric acid. Stock solution B contains 0.1 m od=f sodium citrate that
is stored at a temperature of 2-8 degrees centigrade. The working solution
contains 9 ml of solution A+4 ml of solution B and the final volume of the
solution was adjusted to 500 ml.
Steps of
immuno-staining
Deparaffinization-
The
sectioned paraffin wax was put on a hot plate for 2 minutes so that the wax
melts. The sections were washed under tap water and then are processed to the
next step. The sections embedded in formalin require treatment to remove the
over-fixed antigenic sites. The effective method for the retrieval of the
antigen is microwave treatment.Retrieval
of the epitope by usingcitrate buffer is for the retrieval of the
epitope. The citrate buffer is placed in a glass Coplin or plastic jar. The
slides were immersed vertically in the jar. Then the jar is placed in the
microwave for 5 minutes for 3 cycles of boiling. The buffer is then brought to
a boiling temperature and it was confirmed that the slides were not dried. The
slides are brought to a cooling temperature for 20 minutes. The sections were
rinsed in a washing buffer of 2 changes for 2 minutes each. To block the
binding of immunoglobulin in a non-specific way, the sections were incubated
for 30 minutes in a normal horse serum blocking solution. After the completion
of incubation, the slides were washed for 2 minutes in Tris-buffer saline. The
sections were incubated for 10 minutes in peroxide blocking solutions to
prevent the activity of endogenous peroxidase. The slides were then rinsed in 2
changes of buffer for 2 minutes. The slides were incubated at room temperature
for one hour with the mouse monoclonal or rabbit monoclonal antihuman B cell,
Ki-67. The antibody is removed and the slides were placed for 5 minutes in
buffer saline for washing. The slides were then incubated in a moist chamber
for 80 minutes with a super-enhancer. The slides were rinsed for 2 changes in a
buffer for 2 minutes each. The slides were incubated and diluted at room
temperature for 30 minutes in horseradish peroxidase- streptavidin. The complex
was removed off and the slide is placed for 5 minutes in buffer saline.
Substrate or chromogen: the slides were incubated for 5-10 minutes in
diaminobenzidine peroxide. The slides were then washed in distilled water.
Gills hematoxylin solution was used for counterstaining the slide. The
dehydration of the slide is done through 95 percent of alcohol for 2 minutes,
100 percent of ethanol of 2 changes for 3 minutes each.The slides are cleared
using the xylene and the coverslip is placed over it with permanent mounting.
Interpretation
(Ki-67 score)-The Ki-67 labelling index was calculated
in percentage as the immunostained cells were divided by the total number of
cells present in the evaluated area. A 1000x magnification of oil immersion is
used for counting the cells. Averages of 10 fields were taken and their
standard and mean deviations were calculated. An attempt is made in looking for
the stained positive cells in the maximum density area.
Patterns of staining- Cases
with 0-1 scoring were not included in the study.
Table
2: Staining
patterns of cases with its score
Score |
Staining Pattern |
0 |
Staining is not seen |
1 |
Less than 10 percent
of positive cells are seen |
2 |
10-50 percent of positive cells are seen |
3 |
Greater than 50
percent of positive cells are seen |
RESULTS- This
study considered 235 cases from the Department of Pathology of Ganesh Shankar
Vidyarthi Memorial Medical College, Kanpur, India. The following observations
were made and analyzed. Figure 1 below shows the age distribution of the
patients included in this study. The table shows the maximum number of cases (n=
132; 56.17%) among the age group of 41 years to 60 years. The lowest number of
patients was found in the age group of 81-100 years old.
Fig. 1: Age-wise distribution of cases in this
study
Table
3 below shows the number of patients in each type of carcinoma for each age
group. The table below also shows the percentage of the total patients in each
category. The study found that 7.65% of the patients are having In Situ SCC,
while well-differentiated type, moderately-differentiated type and
poorly-differentiated type accounted for 29.36%, 20.85% and 18.29%, respectively
(Table 3).
Table
3:
Age-wise distribution with the type of carcinoma
Type |
20-40 (yr) |
41-60 (yr) |
60-80 (yr) |
81-100 (yr) |
Total |
In situ SCC |
1 |
15 |
2 |
0 |
18 |
Total patients (%) |
0.4 |
6.38 |
0.85 |
0 |
7.65 |
Well diff. SCC |
16 |
48 |
5 |
0 |
69 |
Total patients (%) |
6.8 |
20.42 |
2.12 |
0 |
29.36 |
Mod. Dif. SCC |
8 |
16 |
22 |
3 |
49 |
Total patients (%) |
3.4 |
6.8 |
9.36 |
1.27 |
20.85 |
Poorly diff. SCC |
0 |
26 |
15 |
2 |
43 |
Total patients (%) |
0 |
11.06 |
6.38 |
0.85 |
18.29 |
SCC with basaloid diff. |
11 |
27 |
26 |
0 |
64 |
Total patients (%) |
4.68 |
11.48 |
11.06 |
0 |
27.23 |
Total |
36 |
132 |
62 |
5 |
235 |
Total patients (%) |
15.31 |
56.17 |
26.38 |
2.12 |
100 |
Fig.
2 shows the number of patients in this study, whose lesion is precancerous and
those, who have a malignant lesion. 162 patients are having large cell invasive
SCC and 55 patients have small cell invasive SCC. There are 18 patients with
the precancerous lesion. Table 3 represents the summary of the distribution of
tumour grades in the patient population.
Fig. 2:
Distribution of tumor grade in the patients
The
study also found that 45.10% of the total patients are post-menopausal. It is
again shown that 14.89% of the total patients are post-menopausal with poorly
diff. SCC, the lesion, which is the most prevalent among post-menopausal
patients. This is followed by Mod. Dif. SCC (13.19%), Well diff. SCC (10.63%)
and SCC with basaloid diff. (6.38%). Table 4 presents the findings of tumor
gradings in postmenopausal patients.
Table 4:
The number of post-menopausal patients in each category of tumor grading
Type |
Total |
Number of
postmenopausal patients |
In situ SCC |
18 |
0 |
Total patients (%) |
7.65 |
0 |
Well diff. SCC |
69 |
25 |
Total patients (%) |
29.36 |
10.63 |
Mod. Dif. SCC |
49 |
31 |
Total patients (%) |
20.85 |
13.19 |
Poorly diff. SCC |
43 |
35 |
Total patients (%) |
18.29 |
14.89 |
SCC with basaloid diff. |
64 |
15 |
Total patients (%) |
27.23 |
6.38 |
Total |
235 |
106 |
Total patients (%) |
100 |
45.10 |
Table 5 shows the average (mean) AgNOR
counts in each grade of malignancy along with respective standard deviation
(SD). The mean value of the Control group came to be 10.62±0.45 while the mean
AgNOR count was found to be 10.62±0.45, 15.10±0.79, 18.39±0.67, 19.75±0.74 and
19.59±0.59 for in-Situ SCC, well-differentiated SCC, moderately differentiated
SCC, poorly differentiated SCC, SCC with basaloid differentiation,
respectively. Table 5 also shows Ki-67 labelling index in each grading of
tumor. Ki-67 score in the control group was found to be 12.71±0.45. With the
increase of grading of the carcinoma, the mean value of Ki-67 score increases
as it can be seen from in Situ SCC with the score of 25.11±0.65, the lowest
one. This is followed by well-differentiated SCC (43.00±1.25), while for
moderately differentiated SCC and poorly differentiated SCC; the score came to
be 48.62±1.56 and 56.54±0.97 respectively. Unlike AgNOR counts in basaloid
differentiation grade, Ki-67 score was found lesser (51.72±0.71) as compared to
poorly differentiated SCC (56.54±0.97).
Table
5:
Mean AgNOR counts and Ki-67 score in each grade of cervical carcinoma
Grade |
No.of cases |
Mean AgNOR and respective SD |
Ki-67 score±SD |
Control |
60 |
10.62±0.45 |
12.71±0.45 |
In
Situ SCC |
18 |
13.97±0.65 |
25.11±0.65 |
Well-differentiated
SCC |
69 |
15.10±0.79 |
43.00±1.25 |
Moderately
differentiated SCC |
49 |
18.39±0.67 |
48.62±1.56 |
Poorly
differentiated SCC |
43 |
19.75±0.74 |
56.54±0.97 |
SCC
with basaloid differentiation |
64 |
19.59±0.59 |
51.72±0.71 |
DISCUSSION-
Potential doubling time has been proposed as a pretreatment estimator of
intra-treatment tumor proliferative capacity. In this study, Ki-67
immunostaining and AgNOR silver staining were examined as a possible alternative
method by comparing them with the doubling time using different cell lines
under varying growth conditions, in vitro. A strong correlation was found
between these scores. Both these had a significant inverse relation with cell
doubling time, potential doubling time, length of S-phase. These values along
with other measures suggest their use as a potential indicator of proliferative
activity [14]. In our present study, the primary conclusion was that
the relationship of AgNOR and Ki-67 immunostaining can be considered for
determining the proliferative activity of tumor.
All pre-treatment biopsy values were
analyzed for tumor proliferative compartment by evaluation of Ki-67 antigen
expression and argyrophilic nucleolar organizer region (AgNOR) counts. Growth
factor analysis was done by analyzing for expression of epidermal growth factor
(EGF), epidermal growth factor receptor (EGF-R), and transforming growth
factors alpha and beta (TGFα, TGFβ). A total of 152 patients were
evaluated and a correlation was obtained between the pre-treatment status of
the tumour-growth-fraction-associated markers and clinical outcome following
radiotherapy. Such patients were either disease-free (group 1, n=106) recurrent
disease (group 2, n=46) at a 16-month follow-up. Pre-treatment analysis of
AgNOR (r=-0.517, p=0.0000). This may be due to the effect of cell
proliferation. Lower AgNOR counts were significantly associated with recurrent
tumors, suggesting that increased proliferative activity may be a positive
prognostic indicator. Similar results were also obtained for the other
proliferation-associated marker Ki-67 (r=-0.443, P=0.0000). Expression of EGF
and EGF-R also showed significant pre-treatment correlations with the final
disease outcome (r=0.248, P=0.031 and r=0.503, P=0.0000, respectively). Both
these markers were expressed more by patients belonging to group2. Group 1
patients showed mostly mild to moderate expression whilst most group 2 patients
were negative for the growth factor. It, therefore, appears that tumors with
high AgNOR counts and Ki-67 index, along with expression of the two types of
transforming growth factor, responded well to radiotherapy [15].
Another study was aimed at assessing the
cell proliferation in various grades of squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix
using two proliferation markers that is AgNOR and Ki-67. 18 biopsy sections of
various grades of squamous cell carcinoma were taken. AgNORs staining was done
by single-step staining technique using gelatin. Ki-67 immunostaining was done
by the Avidin-Biotin technique using DAB as a chromogen. The highest mean
number of AgNORs was found in poorly differentiated squamous cell carcinoma and
statistically, a significant difference was observed between well and poorly
differentiated squamous cell carcinoma and between moderately and poorly
differentiated squamous cell carcinoma. The highest mean Ki-67 was seen in
poorly differentiated squamous cell carcinoma. When observation was made
between histological grade and Ki-67 and AgNORs separately but no statistical
correlation was found between Ki-67 and AgNOR counts. AgNORs and Ki-67 are
simple and easily performed techniques which help determine the management
strategy of the patient [16].
Uterine smooth muscle tumors are the
most common human neoplasms, which are divided into malignant and benign. There
is another set of lesions called smooth muscle tumor of uncertain malignant
potential (STUMP) which does not fit into either of these categories. 21 cases
of the above-mentioned group tumors were randomly collected and were stained
with Ki-67 and Argyrophilicnucleolar organizing regions. Ki-67 was expressed in
63.15% of leiomyosarcomas, 4.76% of STUMPs, and 0% of the leiomyoma group.Ki-67
expression was 2.55±0.03, 2.55. 0.66, 4.04, and 8.12±0.13 in leiomyoma, STUMP,
and leiomyosarcoma, respectively. Differences among the groups were observed [17]. Fifty cases each of cytologically diagnosed
normal, inflammatory, different grades of squamous intraepithelial lesions
(SIL), LSIL, HSIL, and squamous cell carcinoma were registered. In normal
smears, the number of total AgNOR dots ranged from 1 to 2, and in 41.8% of
cases, the dots were pleomorphic. In the inflammatory smears, the number of
AgNOR dots varied from 2 to 3, and the percentage of pleomorphic dots was 45.3%
in the case of HSIL, AgNOR dots varied from 5 to7 with 56.7% pleomorphic dots.
In frank cancer cases, the AgNOR dots were 8-10 with 62.9% pleomorphic dots.
The correlation of cell counts of both pleomorphic and single dots with disease
severity was positive and significant. This reveals that AgNOR pleomorphism
increases with the severity of cytopathological lesions of the cervix. Hence,
pleomorphic dots can be very useful in determining and establishing the
prognosis of the disease and treatment planning [18-20].
Diagnosis
of atypical cells of unspecified importance (ASCUS and AGUS) might help
clinicians carry out further diagnostic procedures to determine the process
going on in the female reproductive system. Qualifying the atypical cells as
neoplastic type or reactive type was done with proliferative potential cells in
cytological smears of Ki-67 and AgNOR. ASCUS had the highest average number of
AgNORs in the cell nucleus. The ratio of AgNORs to that of the cell nucleus was
found to be highest in HSIL and cancer cells, and the east was found in ASCUS.
Thus analysis of AgNORs makes it easier to differentiate ASCUS and LSIL cells
from HSIL and neoplastic ones [21-24]. There is also a well-established
association of cervical cancer with education, area of residence, using
old/unhygienic sanitary napkins, young age at marriage, washing genitalia after
sexual intercourse, number of husband’s partners, and availability of health
care services. Not bathing every day and also during menstruation was found to
be a risk [10].
CONCLUSIONS- The study
confirmed that AgNOR count increases with higher grade of malignancy. Distilled
water also proved to bring better results when used for washing the sample.
Again, the study inferred that Ki-67 score increases with increased malignancy
grade.
The inter-relationship between AgNOR counts and Ki-67
score is a suitable and efficient indicator of proliferative activity. Hence,
AgNOR and Ki-67 score can be used as an efficient predictor of tumor
proliferation.
CONTRIBUTION OF AUTHORS
Research concept- Dr. Neelima Verma
Research design- Dr. Neelima Verma, Dr. Suman Lata Verma
Supervision- Dr. Neelima Verma, Dr. Suman Lata Verma, Dr. Neena Gupta
Materials- Dr. Shadab
Ahmad
Data collection- Dr. Shadab Ahmad, Dr. Neena Gupta
Data analysis and
Interpretation- Dr.
Shadab Ahmad
Literature search- Dr. Shadab Ahmad
Writing article- Dr.
Shadab Ahmad
Critical review- Dr. NeelimaVerma
Article editing- Dr. NeelimaVerma, Dr. Shadab Ahmad
Final approval- Dr. NeelimaVerma, Dr. Shadab Ahmad, Dr. Suman Lata
Verma
REFERENCES